Skip to content
VULKAN Magazine · Print + Digital
Instagram ↗YouTube ↗
VULKAN Magazine
VULKAN / Journal

Front Row

Brad Pitt’s Cliff Booth Returns, and the First Critics Are Swooning

Brad Pitt's Cliff Booth Returns, and the First Critics Are Swooning
Photo: Netflix

Fincher directs, Tarantino writes, Pitt slips back into the role that won him an Oscar. The early reviews of The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth are glowing.

When a script starts at 230 pages and the director cuts 60, you’d expect a tense film. The Cliff Booth first reactions describe the opposite: a loose, funny, good-looking hangout movie that critics say is already one of the year’s best.

The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth, the Netflix-backed sequel to Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, has been shown to the film press. David Fincher directs a screenplay by Quentin Tarantino, with Brad Pitt back as the stuntman he played to an Oscar win. The verdicts landed on social media on November 17, and they are close to unanimous.

Brad Pitt's Cliff Booth Returns, and the First Critics Are Swooning
Photo: Netflix

A sonnet to Los Angeles

Variety’s Clayton Davis called it a “wild, hilarious hangout movie” and said Pitt “slides back into his beloved Oscar-winning role” with his best performance since the 2019 original. Davis also singled out Elizabeth Debicki for bringing “an intoxicating sensuality.” He said Scott Caan and Peter Weller are “such a treat that they could have had triple the screen time.” His verdict on the cinematography: “gorgeous.” Then he took the Los Angeles comparison further than most. “If the 2019 film was a love letter to L.A., this one is a full-on sonnet.”

Several critics reached for the same image. Simon Thompson wrote that the film “pops, throbs and crackles” and is, like its predecessor, a love letter to LA. He called it “a slick and sexy romp” with an “eclectic, ragtag cast.” He described it as “a salty and slower-burning side piece to Tarantino’s original with a fire final act.” Critics Choice member Ricky Válero called it “an aesthetically rich film that beautifully captures the relationship between Los Angeles and the movies.”

The most quotable reaction came from The Wrap’s Drew Taylor. “Tarantino and Fincher are like peanut butter and chocolate,” he wrote, “the peanut butter is profane and the chocolate dipped in blood.” His advice was to see it “on the biggest screen around.” He called the film “an absolute triumph.”

Two sensibilities, one stuntman

The pairing is the draw here. Tarantino wrote the script but chose not to direct. By his own retirement plan he has one more feature left to direct before he leaves the director’s chair for good. Fincher, known for exacting craft, took the job.

Critic Zach Pope framed the result as a “PURE cinematic trifecta of Tarantino’s signature chaos, Fincher’s meticulous attention to detail, and Brad Pitt’s effortlessly charismatic Cliff Booth.” He added that it “never tries to be more than it needs to be.” That may be the line to remember. The early consensus is of a film more interested in good company than in grand statements, and Cliff is described as a character you “just LOVE spending time with.”

Brad Pitt's Cliff Booth Returns, and the First Critics Are Swooning
Photo: Netflix

The story jumps to 1977, eight years after the events of the first film. Cliff is now a Hollywood studio fixer who, as the film’s setup has it, gets in way over his head while working for a popular movie actor. The cast also includes Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and Carla Gugino, along with Debicki, Caan and Weller.

What it means for awards season

None of the critics quoted has made a formal prediction, but the history is worth a look. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood came out from Sony in June 2019 and made $410 million worldwide. It earned 10 Oscar nominations, including best picture and best director. Pitt took best supporting actor for playing Cliff.

That is a high bar for a sequel. Still, the first reactions use the language voters tend to remember. Válero called it “truly one of the year’s best films,” and Davis put Pitt’s work among his strongest. An actor who already owns an Oscar for this character, working with a director whose craft earns the same praise as Pitt’s charisma, will certainly be talked about. First reactions are enthusiastic by nature, and the full critical picture will come into focus once more people have seen the film.

The release plan favours anyone who wants the big-screen experience Taylor recommends. The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth opens exclusively in Imax theaters on November 25. It arrives on Netflix on December 23.

One more detail should please anyone who likes a director’s war stories. Fincher told Empire magazine last month that Tarantino’s first draft ran 230 pages, and that he cut 60. Davis suggests the extra material wasn’t needed, at least in the case of Caan and Weller, who he says could have used triple the screen time.

Via Variety

Explore print + digital editions ↗More stories ↗

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keep reading

Explore all ↗
Nov 18, 2026

Tove Styrke

INTERVIEW BY: Adrienne Strand There’s always more to a song than what we hear. For Tove Styrke, her latest album, I Thought This Story Wasn’t About…